By
"the love," I mean link credit.
The dust seems to have finally settled in a discussion over at
Webmaster World regarding how Google analyzes links from paid directories. The initial post questioned why Google would give credit from a paid directory if they knew it was selling listings.
It was concluded that Google doesn't necessarily give more or less link credit from a paid vs. non-paid directory. It really boils down to whether or not the directory exists to provide a relevant resource or merely to sell or reciprocate links. It may take the Google Team some time (usually a few months) to figure it out but they eventually filter and "discredit" the link farmers. It's not that they want to hand out penalties to directories - it's just that the directories that solely exist to sell or reciprocate links, get in the way of Google's mission for providing the most relevant search results. In a
previous post, I mentioned the symbiotic relationship between search engines and directories. For this reason, directory owners have a responsibility to organize listings (paid or not) in "relevant" categories.
If you are a paid directory, use the funds to employ someone that will review and properly categorize sites that are submitted for possible inclusion. Don't sell links randomly with keyword anchor text in every title. Provide a
unique service. Anyone with decent PageRank can sell links.
If you are a non-profit directory - god bless! My advice: "grow naturally." I would advise against trying to increase popularity by offering a reciprocal link service. It used to be Hot. Now it's Not. Seriously though, reciprocal links can be good to an extent but should not be a main source for growth.
Remember, Google can tell who is linking to whom. If 90% of your inbound links are from sites you are reciprocating a link with, Google will eventually view your site as 10% "important." Directories will pass link credit as long as they provide a relevant resource and grow naturally. Of course it does not hurt to have some "valuable" (non-reciprocated) inbound links from other relevant resources - but how to obtain those is a different story...